Earlier this week, I worked on converting all the brussel sprout haters into brussel sprout lovers. Today I’m coming after the mayonnaise haters. Even if you’re not a hater of mayonnaise, but you don’t really feel strongly about it one way or the other – this mayo is going to change that. You’ll want to put it on ALL THE THINGS.
Also, it’s fast. I called it 5 minute mayo, but that’s only if you’re moving really slowly. You can have it made in 2 minutes if you move with a purpose!
You know how in France, the French dip their french fries in mayo? I always thought that was weird, until I ate this mayo. Then I understood. They do this because they are dipping them in the most delicious thing ever, not store bought mayo with a million ingredients you can’t pronounce, none of them good for you.
Have you ever looked at the ingredient label for mayonnaise that you buy in the store? It’s truly gross. They try to make you think with labeling (“olive oil mayo” and “avocado oil mayo”) that they’re making it healthy. False. They’re putting a dash of their claimed ingredient in, but keeping it full of soybean and other partially hydrogenated oils as well as a bunch of other chemicals you can’t pronounce.
I promise, if you make this mayo, you’ll toss whatever you’ve got in your fridge in and never look back. It’s that delicious! The recipe is a variation of a few recipes I’ve tried over time. They’re all going to have the same basic ingredients (egg, oil, spices) but this is my favorite combo so far.
I’ve given you specific instructions on how to put this together, based on my trials and errors over the years. If you follow these, you should have success in the mayo coming together. It’s an emulsion, so all the ingredients have to be the same temperature before making. This is ESSENTIAL – if you skip this step, you’re going to have failed mayo, which is basically white oil. Not delicious.
The immersion blender is what makes this so easy. If you only have a regular blender or food processor, then you’ll need to keep the blender running and pour the oil in, in the smallest possible stream you can muster, until it’s all gone. (I can tell you, this takes more time out of your life than necessary – just get an immersion blender and whip it up in 2 minutes!)
Once you’ve made your mayo, don’t think of it just as mayonnaise. You can use it for so many different things, including homemade ranch dressing, buffalo chicken casserole, buffalo chicken stuffed sweet potatoes, deviled eggs, and mediterranean tuna salad. I also use it as salad dressing by itself. Don’t knock it ’til you try it – I promise you’ll be a convert once you taste it!
And last but not least, I’d like to leave you with a very important message from Kid President. I don’t get involved in political discussions or voice my opinions on social media, my blog, or anywhere else, unless I am directly asked my thoughts. However, my news feed is currently full of what everyone else thinks, despite me not asking their opinion. They then feel the need to comment and argue with each other, which has nothing to do with me, but is still taking over my social media feed. So, here are my thoughts on that. Worth watching the entire thing, I promise.
Enjoy the video, and your new amazing mayo!
- 1 large egg
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon mustard powder
- 2 Tablespoons lemon juice
- 1 teaspoon vinegar (I prefer apple cider or white wine)
- 1 1/4 cup avocado oil
- In a wide-mouth mason jar, combine the egg, salt, mustard powder, lemon juice, and vinegar.
- Measure oil out into a separate measuring cup.
- Set both side by side on the counter and bring to room temperature (at least an hour, preferably two. Or, do what I do, and leave it all day and come back to it right before bed.)
- Place your immersion blender all the way at the bottom of the jar and pulse once or twice. Add 1/4 cup of the oil and pulse once or twice more.
- Add the remaining oil and continue to run/pulse the immersion blender until a thick mayo forms. This should take less than a minute!
- Store in the fridge in a closed container for up to two weeks.
One batch of mayo makes about 1 1/2 cups total.
If your mayo isn't coming together, you have 1 of 2 problems:
- Your ingredients weren't all the exact same temperature. Make sure they are all on the same place on your counter together while they are coming to room temp!
- You tried to do it in a blender or food processor without reading the post. For this method to work, you HAVE to have an immersion blender. If you're using a blender or food processor, read the post for separate instructions.
I finally tried this method tonight and I’m NEVER going back to making mayo in my regular blender. Seriously…you’re brilliant. This is super tasty too. I LOVE the addition of vinegar. It adds something lovely! I’ll be making your ranch this weekend!
Awesome! So glad you liked it. That little dash of vinegar definitely does add a little something, doesn’t it?! I love how quick it is to make!
Is there a way to replace the egg or just leave it out? What is the lifetime on this mayo
Hi there,
Sorry for the delay, we have a new baby at home! The mayo will last about 2 weeks in the fridge. In regards to the egg, you can’t leave it out – you’d unfortunately end up with just oil and some spices if there was no egg. The mayo is an emulsion, so it comes together by the egg and oil mixing together. I’ve not tried creating it with anything other than egg, but if you find success with something, let us know! 🙂
Has this ever been attempted with egg yolks only?
Hi Danielle! I’ve never tried it with just the yolk, but if you do, I would love to hear how it goes!
I have tried many mayo recipes but can NEVER get it to thicken! Any idea what I could be doing wrong? I was hoping this one would be the one that finally works.:(
Hi Ruth Ann! Two questions for you: 1, are you using an immersion blender or a regular blender/food processor when you make the mayo? The immersion blender is key for this one. If you’re using a regular blender, you will need to drizzle the oil in in the absolute slowest trickle you can muster. It can drive you a little batty; I highly recommend getting an immersion blender if you don’t have one!
And 2, are you making sure your ingredients are all the same temperature (room temp) when you make the mayo? The way I go about it is I crack my egg into the jar, put in the lemon juice, the vinegar, and spices, and set it on the counter and put the bottle of avocado oil next to it on the counter and walk away, then come back later in the day to do the blending. I once had it fail when the oil was in the pantry and the egg on the counter, just because they were two different temps!
I hope that helps; let me know if you’re finally successful!
I tried it again tonight and it finally worked! I did use the immersion blender before but this time I watched a YouTube video first and did it exactly like that and finally had success!
Thank you!:)
Also, what kind oil do you use? I used a light olive oil but wasn’t too fond of the flavor.:(
Yay! I’m so glad to hear you were successful. 🙂 I use avocado oil, as listed in the recipe – I find it has a much milder flavor than the light olive oil.
Raw egg? Does the lemon & vinegar kill any bacteria? Just wondering, I would love to try this!!💜
Yes, raw egg. 🙂 Most homemade mayo recipes call for raw egg. There’s always a small risk eating raw anything, obviously, but I’ve never had an issue here.
I do use local farm eggs, which I feel better about eating raw – knowing the farm they came from and how the chickens were raised/fed. Just my personal preference.
If you’re super concerned, you can always pasteurize the egg before making the mayo. I’ve never done this because I’m lazy, but you’ll just have to be careful that you’re not cooking the egg instead, otherwise you will end up with scrambled eggs in your mayo (yuck!) There’s lots of articles out there on how to pasteurize eggs, here’s just one I found: http://bakingbites.com/2011/03/how-to-pasteurize-eggs-at-home/
Hope that helps!
I buy pasteurized eggs. My local market sells them.
I am allergic to avocados:( what kind of oil could I use instead?
Hi Megan! Sorry for the delay – I just had a baby and am working on catching up!
What you want is an oil that has a mild flavoring, so it doesn’t overpower the mayo. Some people like to use Extra Light Olive Oil, which has a much lighter flavor than regular olive oil. My personal preference in lieu of avocado oil is high oleic safflower oil. Very mild and makes a delicious mayo! Just makes sure to check that it is high oleic. Hope that helps!
This is the second recipe I tried and even went out and got an immersion blender to make it work. It still comes out watery😢
Hi Kassie,
I’m so sorry you’re having trouble with this! You’ll want to make sure you put all your ingredients on the counter in the same place and let them come to room temp together before blending. You’ll also want to keep the immersion blender in the bottom of the jar, and keep it running while you’re pouring the oil in, only lifting it up in the jar after it starts to thicken. Let me know if you have questions, I’d love to help you make your first successful batch! 🙂
Is this Whole30 approved?
Hi Kaylie,
Yes, it is! As long as you use a W30 compliant oil (which avocado oil is!) then you are good to go.
I am making this and it’s been way longer than 5 minutes and it super watery. 🙁 I did everything the recipe calls for. Using an immersion blender, let all the ingredients sit side by side for an hour and a half, and still no luck. My immersion blender is getting hot because it’s been running for so long. I don’t know what to do as I don’t want to waste a cup and a quarter of avocado oil. Help!
Hi Amelia!
I’m so sorry to hear that your emulsion failed. If you don’t see the mayo come together in a minute or two in the future, you can stop – it won’t come together the longer you run the blender, unfortunately. Every once in awhile there is a rare instance where the mayo fails – it happens to everyone (including me!) You can save the failed mayo by basically starting over, but instead of using oil, you’re using the failed mayo. Here’s a quick YouTube demo to show you how: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TrkH3n_kqZ0
I hope that helps, and I’m sorry this happened to you! Hopefully next time everything will come together. Try setting everything out in the morning, then making the mayo in the afternoon – perhaps the longer room temp time will help.
I am missing a piece of my immersion blender so had to use my Blendtec and it’s super runny. Will it set or do I just need to try again?
Hi Jennifer,
So, I detail this in the post as well, but if you’re using a regular blender, the method is different. Because this is an emulsion, a regular blender doesn’t have the same effect on the ingredients that the immersion blender does. For a regular blender or food processor, you have to run it on low, continuously, while drizzling the oil in in the absolute smallest stream you can muster. I used to make mayo this way before I had an immersion blender, and I can tell you, it’s somewhat excruciating. It should take you about 10-15 minutes to drizzle in this much oil. That being said, it can be done, but if you can find or replace the missing piece of your immersion blender, you’ll find yourself with a bit more free time on your hands. 🙂 Best of luck!
How much does usually make in your opinion?
Hi Patrick,
The recipe makes about 1 1/4 cups of mayo.
I am so glad I tried this recipe. It came out perfect!
I made mayo for the first time a few weeks ago and stupidly used evoo. It was very strong and took forever in my food processor. I tried it again with your method ( I added 2 yolks bc I had them leftover from breakfast, and used extra light oil) and it came out perfectly and tastes great.
Hi Sunni,
I’m so glad you liked it! Regular EVOO and a food processor are honest mayo mistakes – I’ve made both of them in the past! But now you know the easy way and can move forward with simple, delicious mayo. Next up, try turning it into my ranch dressing!
https://www.paleoscaleo.com/homemade-ranch-dressing/
Would a hand mixer work instead of an immersion blender?
Hi Megan, unfortunately not! The immersion blender I recommend is linked in the post. It’s totally worth the 20 bucks – you can use it for other stuff, too, like blending soups right in the pot. (My tomato soup and curried sweet potato soup are great candidates!) The other option for the mayo would be a regular blender or food processor. If you use one of these, you’ll need to follow the specific instructions in the post – keep it running the whole time, and drizzle the oil in slowly, in as small a stream as you can muster, until it comes together and makes mayo! This takes quite a bit longer and is easier to mess up, but it’s how I started making mayo and can definitely be done with a steady hand and some patience.
I’m am trying to exclude vinegar from my diet – any substitutions you recommend? Just more lemon juice?? Or exclude all together?
Thanks!
Hi Jennifer! You can just leave out the vinegar. It adds a little flavor, but I doubt you’ll miss it and the mayo will still come together without it.
Hello, I’m curious about the calorie count. It says 12 calories per serving, but the Avocado Oil alone is 2,400 calories. If I divide that by 24, I get 100 calories a serving. Am I missing something?
P.S. I made the ranch and am enjoying it. The hubs didn’t care for the strong dill taste.
Hi Miranda! Thanks for reaching out about this. The nutrition information is calculated by a recipe plugin based on their database. I always recommend that if you need exact numbers to make sure to confirm them on your own. That being said, the avocado oil is coming in at 240 calories total, not 2400, which might be where the disconnect is! Glad to hear you like the ranch. You could always try adjusting the dill to be a bit less and see if hubby likes it better that way?
Thank you for responding. Yes I can play with the deal and see if he likes it better but I really enjoyed it. So you’re saying they are calculator thanks a cup of oil only has 240 calories? Yes that would be a big difference .I wish I only had 240 calories! Ha
Hi Miranda! Wasn’t saying it was right, just saying that’s how it was being calculated. 🙂 Unfortunately technology sometimes hinders rather than helps us. I went back and switched it to ml and the API seems to be converting correctly now, showing the 100+ calories and 12g fat per serving. Hope that helps!
Love this simple recipe that only requires a few ingredients. Immersion blender works Great ! Thanks for sharing, did take more than a few minutes but lovely results.
Hi Chris! So glad you liked it! It’s a staple in our house.